Big Dom's Bagel Shop

New Bagel Shop Fills Familiar Downtown Location

Cary, NC – Professionals in Downtown Cary have a new place for breakfast on the way to work as the owners of Pizzeria Faulisi open a bagel shop, complete with a unique baking method.

Downtown Bagels

Big Dom’s Bagel Shop is opening in Downtown Cary on E Chatham Street, in the former Little Caesars location. Owner Zach Faulisi, who also owns nearby Pizzeria Faulisi, said they had been eyeing the store as a possible location they would want to pursue and will be using the Little Caesars ovens for their bagels and other baked goods.

Faulisi said he and his wife had been selling bagels they made in the wood fire oven at Pizzeria Faulisi since 2017.

“We had been doing pop-up markets on Saturdays for six months. I wanted to test our oven and see what else we could make in there,” Faulisi said. “With the wood fire oven, they were like Montreal-style bagels but the ones we’ll sell [at Big Dom’s] are a mix between New York-style and Montreal-style.”

The bagels made here will also use a different baking method than typical, as Faulisi explained it. Usually, bagels are put on a wooden paddle when baking and then later flipped onto a hearth.

“Because of the shape of our wood fire oven, I put the dough on a sheet pan with Crisco. It gives the bagel that perfect brown ring and it absorbs the Crisco,” Faulisi said, comparing the taste to pan-fried chicken. While Big Dom’s will not use the wood fired oven, Faulisi said they will still use this sheet pan and Crisco method.

In addition to bagels, the store will sell biscuits and “b’donuts” or baked doughnuts, all made with hand-rolled dough. Faulisi said the b’donuts are like cake doughnuts, made using sweet potatoes.

“When you add something like a sweet potato, it makes the doughnut moist,” he said.

The current plan is for Big Dom’s Bagel Shop to open before the end of 2018.

Big Dom's Bagel Shop

Zach Faulisi

Attention to Flavor

Between baking pizza dough and baking dough for bagels and b’donuts, Faulisi said there are some similarities that his pizza-making experience gives him but said there are differences in the dough hydration as well as the preparation of the dough before making bagels. But for the dough at Big Dom’s, Faulisi said they are using a cold rise method on the dough overnight.

“That way, we’re developing flavor over time,” he said.

Faulisi also said the store will use local ingredients where they can, not only to support local farmers but also because of the quality of the produce.

“The agriculture here is well taken care of,” he said. “In North Carolina, there’s a real appreciation for what farmers do.”

The flour used will come from North Carolina farms, as will the sweet potatoes.

To make the ordering and eating process convenient for customers, Faulisi said they are looking into getting an app so people can pre-order their food and also utilize the existing drive-thru window on the building for pick-up. Also, Faulisi said they will add a counter-top rail around the windows.

“We want to give it that big city feel,” he said.

Big Dom’s Bagel Shop is located at 203 E Chatham St.

Big Dom's Bagel Shop


Story by Michael Papich. Photos by Michael Papich and Big Dom’s Bagel Shop. 

Coverage on CaryCitizen is sponsored in part by Thai Spices & Sushi.

Click to visit

First time commenter? Please read our Comments Policy. Comments are at the discretion of the Publisher.


2 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.